Under Putin, Russia Culture Perishes

The Associated Press reports:

A squirrel tail. Wolf teeth. Sheets of gold. Flax oil.

These are the things Vladimir Buldakov uses to work a feat of modern-day alchemy: transforming an ordinary papier-mache box into a gilded miniature masterpiece that will tell the story of saints or heroes, fairies or dragons.

Buldakov comes from Palekh, a 700-year-old Russian village where a church’s lavender onion-domes overlook snow-clad houses, a frozen river and a distant birch forest. The town is famous for its beauty, but the rare outsiders who visit come for the varnished boxes that bear its name.

Now, the unique art form, which emerged in the 1920s after the atheist Bolsheviks approved a new medium in which masters of religious icon paintings could use their talents, is struggling to find a reason to exist in capitalist society.

If it disappears entirely, its stunted lifespan will bear vivid testament to the twists of Russia’s turbulent recent history. And Russia will lose one if its hallmark trinkets, the product of an astonishingly high-skilled process.

In Palekh, the 60-year-old Buldakov’s fine brush is made from a squirrel caught in August — any later and the fur splits. He boils the papier-mache in flax oil to make it stone hard. After painting and varnishing, he applies tiny specks of gold kneaded in gum arabic, and smooths the surface with a wolf’s tooth.

The box will take months to complete. For the backbreaking labor, he will be lucky to get a few thousand dollars. Buldakov and his wife Natalya are masters or their craft; less talented artists struggle to command a couple hundred dollars a box.

With demand falling, that’s hardly enough to keep his daughter Kseniya keen on carrying on a family tradition that goes back five generations. She trained as a Palekh box painter but moved to St. Petersburg to make dolls at a puppet theater, which is less arduous.

“It doesn’t make sense to work with the boxes,” the 30-year-old says, adding that most others of her generation feel the same way. “Very few of them stay … Everyone wants to get out, it’s cramped and boring.” Back in Soviet times, Palekh boxes were a heavily subsidized art that made their makers relatively rich. But in these days of globalization and free-wheeling capitalism, where oil oligarchs have become some of the world’s richest men, the lure of making boxes for modest earnings that dwindle every year is fading fast.

Even young people who like Kseniya Buldakova graduated from the Palekh art college, where her father teaches, now work as software designers, cartoonists, teachers and even manicurists, astounding clients with the intricate details their studies allow them to paint on nails.

Palekh is not alone on the list of famous Russian village handicrafts — wooden toys from Bogorodsk, blue majolica ceramics from Gzhel, iron trays from Zhostovo, to name a few — that may soon become history. The trend runs deeper because traditional ways Russians eat, dress and dance are also fading.

It’s hard to find the massive wood-fired brick ovens that once dominated each household. They were essential for steam baths and traditional cooking, and their replacement gas stoves made “a whole class of traditional Russian foods extinct,” according to food historian Vilyam Pokhlyobkin. Teenagers shun traditional valenki felt boots in favor of Chinese-made sneakers and sneer at traditional folk music and dance; aspiring musicians prefer electric guitars and synthesizers to accordions and balalaikas — decimating the ranks of their makers.

Artisans blame the decline in Russian crafts largely on an industrial recession in a country where plants and factories can compete neither with the sophistication of Western technologies nor the cheapness of Chinese manufacturing. “Matryoshkas are now made in China and brought here,” said Sophia Panfilova, the 54-year old owner of a souvenir shop outside the Kremlin, who has also been painting these nesting dolls for more than 20 years.

Palekh painters don’t advertise their works online for fear their designs will be replicated on high-resolution prints glued to boxes, then varnished. One artist, Nikolai Kukuliev, recalls how his stout, white-bearded father Boris angrily rushed out of a Moscow souvenir shop after seeing a knockoff box with his design.

“Why is the grandpa mad at me? I’ll give him a good discount for the box,” the salesman told Kukuliev. “Grandpa was the author,” Kukuliev shot back.
Perhaps most fatal has been the drying up of lavish state subsidies. The Palekh miniature emerged and flourished because communist ideologues chose it as a poster child of Soviet art. For centuries, Palekh was a center of icon painting, but after the 1917 Bolshevik revolution, artists switched to secular scenes and the nascent communist propaganda.

Soviet leaders were flattered to see themselves painted as martyrs and saints. Back then, Palekh masters and other centers of handicrafts enjoyed benefits, state medals, and scrupulous attention from culture officials who had to approve each sketch.

Across Russia, artisans’ villages were often islands of prosperity surrounded by an ocean of dirt-poor collective farms. A government monopoly also sold most of the artistic output abroad or in specialized shops for foreign tourists.
“Sales were not our headache,” says Maxim Churikov, director of the

Fedoskino factory outside Moscow that, like Palekh, produces lacquered boxes often encrusted with fragments of mother-of-pearl, silver or gold. The 1991 Soviet collapse brought artistic freedom, including a return to religious themes, and an unprecedented boom for Palekh, whose miniatures were sought after by foreign museums and collectors.

But the boom ended in bust, as Western demand for Palekh boxes dwindled. Few handicraft centers these days enjoy state financial support, meaning it’s hard to survive without proximity to Moscow that brings buses of foreign tourists or affluent Russian weekenders. Palekh lies 340 kilometers (200 miles) northeast of the capital, a bumpy five-hour drive.

The return to religious themes also dealt a blow to Palekh miniatures. As the triumphant Russian Orthodox Church began reopening thousands of churches and monasteries across the nation, the demand for icons soared, prompting many students at the Palekh art college to take up the once-forgotten art. But Palekh artists say icons that have to be thoughtlessly copied from ancient originals leave no room for creativity. “There is a danger we might turn into a school of icon painters,” said college director Mikhail Belousov.

3 responses to “Under Putin, Russia Culture Perishes

  1. Now, the unique art form, which emerged in the 1920s after the atheist Bolsheviks approved a new medium in which masters of religious icon paintings could use their talents, is struggling to find a reason to exist in capitalist society….. The return to religious themes also dealt a blow to Palekh miniatures. As the triumphant Russian Orthodox Church began reopening thousands of churches and monasteries across the nation, the demand for icons soared, prompting many students at the Palekh art college to take up the once-forgotten art. But Palekh artists say icons that have to be thoughtlessly copied from ancient originals leave no room for creativity.

    In other words, this article says that atheism and communism are good for the arts, while religion/Christianity and capitalism are bad? Interesting…

    • The article says nothing like that. It says that the Palek artisans, specifically, prospered before but not know. Some other traditional crafts are mentioned, but not much about their plight or thriving, other than the mentioning of “decline.”

      In the article, I see no conclusions regarding the arts. It’s you who are making this generalization, not the author of the piece, who is only discussing certain crafts, not arts. I don’t see a word about music, poetry, sculpture, ballet, theater or other fields falling into the arts category.

  2. Maimuni,

    If that is a taste of your reasoning capabilities, then you have serious problems thinking rationally.

    Reread the article, slowly this time, before making any more absurd “predictions”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s