Vera Trifonova, RIP

Vera Trifonova, RIP. Before, and after, Vladimir Putin went to work on her.

Other Russia reports:

Nearly half a year has passed since Sergei Magnitsky’s scandalous death in a Moscow detention center sparked international outrage at Russia’s penitentiary system. Now, in a case that bears an unsettling resemblance to Magnitsky’s, a Russian businesswoman awaiting trial on charges of fraud has died in the same detention center. And like Magnitsky, her lawyer alleges that the woman died as a result of being denied necessary medical care.

According to Russian Federal Penitentiary Service representative Sergei Tsygankov, the 53-year-old Vera Trifonova died at 12:35 pm on April 30, 2010, in the intensive care unit of the hospital at the Matrosskaya Tishina criminal investigation detention facility (SIZO) in Moscow. Local police were called to the scene, established that there were no signs that the death has been violent, and have launched an investigation.

Trifonova’s lawyer, Vladimir Zherebenkov, told the rights organization Justice that his client was refused proper medical care to such an extent as to constitute an intent towards her “physical destruction.”

According to a press release from the organization, medics had diagnosed the businesswoman with severe diabetes and had determined that she had only one working kidney.

Zherebenkov explained that Trifonova’s health began to sharply declined when she was arrested in December 2009 and placed in Matrosskaya Tishina. When she complained that her lungs were filling with liquid, she was brushed off and told to “sleep standing up.” After demands by her lawyer, Trifonova was eventually moved to a Moscow city hospital, where she immediately recovered. Doctors at the hospital confirmed that Trifonova required specialized treatment that included regular cleansings of her blood – a procedure not possible at the detention facility.

At that point, says the lawyer, Investigator Sergei Pysin told Trifonova that she would get different accommodations if she plead guilty to the fraud she was charged with. The woman refused, and despite doctors’ orders that Trifonova not leave the hospital even for investigative proceedings, Pysin brought her back to Matrosskaya Tishina.

Zherebenkov believes that Pysin had at that point prepared a medical document from Matrosskaya Tishina doctors declaring Trifonova’s condition to be stable and fit for investigative proceedings. On the basis of that document, he says, Odintsovsky Court judge Olga Makarova turned down Trifonova’s April 16 request to be released on bail, and instead extended her detention for another three months.

That same day, the press release goes on, a decision was made to move Trifonova to a female penal colony in Mozhaysk, seventy miles west of Moscow. Officials at the penal colony refused to admit her, however, and she was taken to the Mozhaysk city hospital. According to Zherebenkov, doctors at the hospital did not know how to help the woman because they lacked the proper equipment to cleanse her blood, a procedure that she needed two to three times a week.

In the days that followed, the investigator repeatedly promised the Zherebenkov that they would find some way to move Trifonova to a hospital outfitted for her condition. But in the meantime, the businesswoman’s condition was quickly deteriorating. On April 26, the lawyer resorted to using an ambulance rented by Trifonova’s relatives to bring her to a local medical institute to undergo treatment.

Trifonova was finally brought back to Matrosskaya Tishina on April 29, and was supposed to have been brought back to the original hospital in Moscow today. As is now obvious, it was already too late.

“They purposefully destroyed her, and sent her to the Mozhaysk prison so that she would die there,” says Zherebenkov. He believes that the investigator “filled the order” of one of Trifonova’s business partners who owed her several million dollars.

According to RIA Novosti, officials from the Federal Penitentiary Service responded to the lawyer’s accusations that Trifonova was denied medical care by referring to the fact that the paperwork ordering her to undergo medical evaluation had needed to be signed by the investigator “who disappeared somewhere and we were unable to get in touch with him.”

Zherebenkov says he plans to file a criminal suit against Pysin and appeal to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. “Vera Trifonova repeated the fate of Sergei Magnitsky, because our SIZOs are instruments of torture and a means to pressure people,” he said.

The press release from Justice, the main source of information for this article, is available in Russian by clicking here.

14 responses to “Vera Trifonova, RIP

  1. Memory Eternal.

  2. Just watch how the ruSSophile stooges will stay silent on this topic.

    Or if they reply, it will be pure irrelevance!

    • Yes, agreed entirely.

      What do you have to say to this Voice of Retardation, Ouch, Svanidze?

    • What is there to discuss? That’s awful.

      If the things her lawyer says are true, he should file a suit against the penetentiary system and win it.

      • Yes, like you really can win monetary damages from the government in Russia. This is just as plausible as that statement made by one of your fellow Russians about Russia being a free country.

      • Dima, you can win cases against the state in Russia, the problem is they hardly ever pay up.
        Plus the problem is that this poor woman is not alone, thousands of people are being kept in jail here, sometimes on laughable or trumped up charges.
        Take the mayor of Smolensk, Kachanovski for instance, the guy’s been held in jail for several months on charges of bribery and even though all the evidence is highly questionable the judge has refused bail in repeated hearings.
        Reminds me of this joke I heard recently, in Russia we have this idiom when somebody is jailed people often say they ‘landed’ (the implication being they landed in jail), so this recent joke goes like this, ‘what’s the difference between Kachanovski and Kachinski? One landed and the other crashed’ A bit callous but funny, imho.

        • Oh, I see the problem you’re talking about. But in reality, Hague court decisions are fulfilled, as not paying out the compensation may be the cause of an arrest of Russian government property.

          Also, please check the new legislation on compensation of delay in fulfilling the court decisions:

          • Hague or Strasbourg? I thought it was the latter.

          • And sometimes as in the case of this unfortunate business woman, compensation can’t do any good, a lot of people actually end up dying in jail, she’s not the only one and how can our government compensate for that?
            This practice of locking people up before trial is a manifestation of the presumption of guilt on which our law enforcement system operates, in most ‘normal’ countries a person suspected of committing a crime is presumed innocent until proven guilty in Russia, it’s the other way around, by default everyone is presumed guilty until they manage to prove otherwise. Sure enough officials pay lip service to presumption of innocence but in practice 9 times out of 10 people are locked up without bail because they are presumed to be guilty

  3. using inhumane treatment as method to extract a confession is completely unconstitutional.
    russian consitution is essentially lip service to the rest of the world.
    most of what it calls for doesn’t exist in russia.
    russian consitution doesn’t declare principles of operation of government.
    instead it refers to laws and makes certain individual rights conditional of lawful behavior of said individual, making it basically meaningless and full of circular dependencies.
    the truth is, russian society is just not ready for real change. this society doesn’t want to live by the rule of law. this becomes evident when even in traffic on a two lane road that becomes a 4 lane road. this becomes evident when they give bribes. yes, it’s not all about taking bribes. it’s about giving bribes too. it’s cultural. people will give bribes to get ahead, it’s not considered bad taste, in fact, just the opposite. it’s cultural.
    and of course, you can’t tell them this is “wrong”. they know better what’s wrong and what’s right. after all, this isn’t just russia. 80% of the world lives like this. and anyone who tells you bribing is bad is called a “russofob”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s