Felgenhauer says War in Caucasus Looms

The always brilliant Pavel Felgenhauer, writing on the Jamestown Foundation’s Eurasia Daily Monitor:

It is early springtime and in the mountain passes separating Georgia from Russia, there is snowfall one day and wet snow or rain the next. Avalanches and mudslides caused by wet snow regularly close down the only road connecting Russia and the breakaway region of South Ossetia through the Roki Tunnel (RIA Novosti, March 9). Low clouds and fog in the mountains keep Russian helicopters and jets grounded for days and weeks. But in two months, the weather will be fine. In May the last snow will melt on the high mountain passes and it will be wartime again in the region.

The period when war was physically impossible in the Caucasus is now almost over, but the halfhearted attempts by European Union mediators to strengthen the ceasefire have accomplished virtually nothing. Last month at Russia’s request, the EU-sponsored peace talks in Geneva were suspended until the end of June (RIA Novosti, February 19). Since Moscow refuses to have any contacts with Tbilisi outside the Geneva format, this four-month adjournment is potentially a very bad sign.

The ceasefire continues to be fragile, with both sides trading mutual accusations and sometimes sporadic live fire. The OSCE, United Nations, and unarmed EU observers lack the mandate or the capability to separate the opposing forces or impose a permanent and sustainable truce. The monitors are unarmed; they cannot perform even minimal police functions to prevent banditry and looting in the immediate cease-fire zone. So there is no force disengagement at all-armed Georgian police are deployed at the cease-fire line in direct contact with the Abkhaz and South Ossetian military, which makes constant armed incidents virtually inevitable.

The South Ossetian leader Eduard Kokoity claimed last week, “There are about 2,500 armed men currently deployed and building fortifications within the conflict zone on the Georgian side,” while the EU observers were “contributing to the worsening of the situation” (RIA Novosti, March 6). The EU mission has repeatedly stated that it does not see any Georgian force concentrations in the cease-fire zone. The Ossetians respond by accusing the EU mission of “deliberately ignoring Georgian preparations for military aggression” (Interfax, February 9).

These inflammatory statements and intermittent clashes could easily escalate into a new major conflict when the warm wartime season comes to the Caucasus. To make things worse, it has been announced that Abkhazia and South Ossetia will soon begin to implement agreements with Russia to jointly patrol their “borders with Georgia” (Interfax, March 11). This may bring more Russian servicemen into harm’s way in the area of intermittent clashes. Any injury of Russian solders that might be attributable to Georgian forces could serve as a casus belli.

There is growing political unrest in Georgia with different opposition factions demanding the resignation of President Mikheil Saakashvili (RIA Novosti, March 10). Giorgi Targamadze, leader of the Christian-Democratic Party, the main parliamentary opposition, is more cautious: “It is dangerous to push Saakashvili into a corner.” The nation needs reforms, not a “revolution,” and opposition forces lack the resources to actually overthrow the present regime. Targamadze believes that “Russia may attempt to set us against each other to make us do its job” (Civil Georgia, March 6). Other opposition figures are much more outspoken. Former Prime Minister Zurab Noghaideli, called Saakashvili a “traitor and a coward,” while the former speaker of parliament, Nino Burjanadze, described his government as “criminal” (Moscow Times, March 10).

On the government side there is also confusion. Last week at a security conference in Riga, Latvia, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Euro-Atlantic Integration (as well a former defense minister) Grigori Baramidze told me that he saw a lot of arguments why “Russia may resume its aggression and very little in favor of peace.” Baramidze told the conference that “Russia could use internal instability in Georgia for another assault.” Defense Minister Davit Sikharulidze announced last week, “We must prepare to defend our motherland against an invasion” (Civil Georgia, March 7).

At the same time, Saakashvili has announced, “The possibility of a resumption of hostilities has been reduced, but nothing is yet fully guaranteed” (Civil Georgia, March 11). The powerful interior minister, Vano Merabishvili, who is in charge of counterintelligence, has publicly “ruled out” any possibility of “a renewal of Russia’s large-scale military aggression.” Merabishvili insisted that talk of a possible renewal of Russian aggression has been deliberately disseminated by Moscow itself to trigger panic in Georgia and scare off investors. Merabishvili added that peaceful opposition protests would be allowed but that his ministry had “enough resources to prevent any unlawful actions” (Civil Georgia, March 7).

Last August Russian troops invaded Georgia to “enforce peace” and defend the Ossetian and Abkhaz minorities, imitating NATO actions in ex-Yugoslavia. This year, if the Interior Ministry riot police are deployed to disperse protesters, Moscow may go in for “regime change” to liberate Christian Orthodox Georgians from Saakashvili.

There are still several weeks left for the West to recognize the imminent threat and begin a high-level round of shuttle diplomacy to compel or coerce all sides to genuinely strengthen the ceasefire and disengage forces. Moscow must understand all the disadvantages of a new crisis and agree to strengthen the observer mission’s mandate. The Georgians must find a way to contain internal political strife. The Ossetian and Abkhaz leaders must stop mindlessly provoking a new war. In short, a miracle is needed.

12 responses to “Felgenhauer says War in Caucasus Looms

  1. “Upon the Georgian hills there lies the haze of night
    Aragva murmurs underneath.
    I’m sad, but my soul is light, my sorrow’s bright,
    My sorrow’s filled with you. ” A.S.Puskin(russian poet)

    And my sorrow is filled with Georgia.
    Georgia, where every nation lived in peace.
    Not afraid that crazy prezident will give an order
    to start shelling with “Grad” peacefully sleeping town.

    • You mean, Yeltsin & Putin and Grozny?

      • Well said Robert,

        Or maybe they mean the Russian & Abkhazian bombing and shelling of Sukhumi in 1993, and the murder of more than 30,000 Georgian civillians during the Russian sponsored ethnic cleansing?

  2. Quote:”This year, if the Interior Ministry riot police are deployed to disperse protesters, Moscow may go in for “regime change” to liberate Christian Orthodox Georgians from Saakashvili.”
    If they realy wanted to change regime the would do it last august, the way was clear.
    Georgians must free themselves.

  3. Quote:”The South Ossetian leader Eduard Kokoity claimed last week, “There are about 2,500 armed men currently deployed and building fortifications within the conflict zone on the Georgian side,” while the EU observers were “contributing to the worsening of the situation” (RIA Novosti, March 6). The EU mission has repeatedly stated that it does not see any Georgian force concentrations in the cease-fire zone. The Ossetians respond by accusing the EU mission of “deliberately ignoring Georgian preparations for military aggression” (Interfax, February 9).”

    The same things happened last spring till August.
    Osetians told that Georgia plans to begin the war, OSCE answered that there is nothing to worry about

    • Actually “Sphynx”, there were multiple Separatist attacks on the Georgians prior to the Georgian attack on the separatists.

      As for “If they realy wanted to change regime the would do it last august, the way was clear.”

      • As for “As for “If they realy wanted to change regime the would do it last august, the way was clear.”

        As Felgenhauer and several other commentators pointed out, the Russian military lost control and choesion of their troops once they started looting and raping thier way through Georgian towns, even robbing banks and stealing the toilets from schools.

        The Russians also expected (rather stupidly as usual) that there would be an uprising against Saakashvili, not thinking that even the opposition would support him against an external enemy.

        Now the Russians are most likely going to try again.

  4. Good article. No any tales about “russian trap” for Georgia.

  5. Requesting a return to comment moderation again. No spam, no non-Latin alphabets, no stupid comments.

  6. RaSSiya has too much time on its hands and the means to be messing with everybody. Intelligent pressure must be universally applied by the whole world at the same time.

    No more G8, No Sochi Olympics, No more Security Council Membership. No NATO participation. No Visas. Nothing!

    Being inexperienced Obama sent Hilary with a Reset button. This can work both ways. This is not a forgiveness button, that Moscali can keep pressing. Nor a Token of Weakness, which encourages bastards to do worse.

    Moscali can only understand a brick in the face, or threats to their financial system. Moscali know that China is focusing on their territory, and would win any conventional or non conventional war. Just too many, they could march a column 50 across into the sea and not run out of troops. Scares them to death.

    RaSSiyan conscripts used to being pimped off, would drop their guns and run. Too bad, as that the worst of the scum usually get away.

  7. Sphincter, were you just born? Everyone knows you are a Russian FSB stooge. Going around quoting the warlord Kokoityev and expecting people to take you as some beatnik friend of the Georgian people! You buffoon, go back to the cave you crawled out of you trog.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s